Tomahawks have been and are nonetheless wanted as a light-weight multipurpose out of doors instrument.
Their small dimension makes them ultimate for being carried within the hand, on a beltline, or hooked up to a pack.
They work properly for chopping, digging, processing game, processing wood, hammering, scraping, could be thrown, and work properly as a private weapon.
In this text I’ll evaluate two tomahawks from two well-known knife corporations: the Rifleman’s Tomahawk by Cold Steel vs. the Kangee by CRKT.
Does one of many hawks stand above the opposite? Let’s discover out collectively by first looking on the Rifleman’s Tomahawk.
Cold Steel Rifleman’s Tomahawk Specifications
The head of the tomahawk is constituted of 5150 carbon metal
The leading edge is Three ½” and with a hammerhead on the again.
The American Hickory deal with is 22” lengthy
The Rifleman weighs in at 1lb 10oz.
Upon unboxing this tomahawk there’s a sticker proper throughout the steel head that claims, “American Tomahawk Company.”
I really feel that I would like to deal with this as a result of it has drawn many complaints from clients who don’t suppose they’re getting a Cold Steel product.
Part of the confusion lies in that there’s one other firm known as “American Tomahawk Company.”
These two corporations will not be affiliated with each other, and the American Tomahawk Company sticker is utilized by Cold Steel on their tomahawks.
i’ve been a Cold Steel purchaser for years and i’ve been very pleased with each buy i’ve made. Having stated that, I can not consider what arrived within the mail.
To be honest, I didn’t buy the Rifleman immediately from Cold Steel however a vendor.
I’m all for chopping heads which have some character to them after years of use however after I pulled the Rifleman’s Tomahawk from the container I couldn’t consider I used to be holding a Cold Steel product.
The steel head was closely pitted and scratched, the end was coming off and peeling, the leading edge was boring and there was floor rust all through the top!
These are primarily aesthetic points that didn’t have any impact on the operation of the tomahawk, however I nonetheless felt like I wanted to deal with this nonetheless.
During regular occasions i’d have despatched this again however on condition that transport occasions these days are anybody’s guess, I made a decision to maintain the tomahawk and repair these points myself.
Testing It Out
With all merchandise that I take a look at, I achieve this as they arrive proper out of the container. The Rifleman wanted to be sharpened however I made a decision to depart it as is, no less than initially.
At 1lb 10ouncesit isn’t heavy within the hands however has sufficient weight behind it to get some severe work accomplished.
Not being overly heavy permits for this instrument to be simply carried on the beltline or a pack.
The straight Hickory deal with feels nice within the hand. I’m joyful that there’s not a thick lacquer end on it like there’s on the Kangee. This helped to maintain a agency grip on the deal with when in use.
The 22” deal with is simply the precise size that allowed me to make use of this hawk each one and two-handed. Being capable of comfortably use two hands makes chopping duties far more efficient.
I began out chopping by means of small diameter limbs and moved my approach as much as roughly one half inch diameter items.
The hawk dealt with these properly and I used to be capable of get by means of all the items in a single swing.
I moved on to a chunk of Cedar that was roughly three inches in diameter. It was right here that I began to note the blade bouncing off the wood greater than digging into it.
Part of this needed to do with the leading edge being reasonably boring proper out of the container.
Regardless, I used to be capable of get by means of the wood and course of the limb with minimal effort.
Lastly, I made a decision to start out swinging at some larger logs. The log in entrance of me was roughly ten inches in diameter and that I had no intention of chopping all the methods by means of it.
I took ten full swings and produced a pleasant V reduce. The blade bit into the wood properly however not sufficient that it turned caught with each swing.
The few occasions the blade did turn into caught within the wood, the 22” deal with made it simpler to take away.
This hawk is each extremely fulfilling and cozy to swing.
The peace pipe design of the Rifleman presents a leading edge on one facet of the steel head and a flat head on the rear.
The flat head presents an excellent strong floor for hammering nails, stakes, and another impression duties an individual might run into.
The hammer facet of the top had no downside driving a few three-inch nails into the stump I exploit as a workbench or pounding stakes into the bottom that have been shortly made with the hawk.
I grabbed an allen wrench and eliminated the setscrew on the facet of the top.
With the setscrew eliminated, the top simply slid down the deal with. At the highest of the deal with what place the top was located, there was a good sized gap within the wood from the screw digging into it.
When utilizing the hawk, numerous the drive goes to be transferred to the screw which in flip will start digging away on the wood. This damages the deal with and can ultimately trigger the top to turn into unfastened.
If your intentions with the Rifleman are to make use of it as a showpiece then the setscrew could be left in place.
However, should you intend on utilizing this tomahawk commonly outdoor then there are two explanation why i’d advocate eradicating it.
The first is that it damages the deal with as I discussed above.
Secondly, I don’t carry allen wrenches in my gear so i’d not be capable of make changes, and changing a damaged deal with can be tougher as a result of screw.
After eradicating the screw, you’ll want to correctly set the hawk head by inverting the deal with and pounding it multiple occasions on a tough floor. Simply sliding the top to the tip of the deal with is not going to maintain it in place.
i’m not much for throwing tomahawks although many individuals get pleasure from doing so.
I didn’t throw the Rifleman however all the critiques i’ve seen, report that it throws exceptionally properly and hits exhausting.
Lastly, I wished to get a fireplace going utilizing nothing greater than the Rifleman and a ferrocerium rod.
The head of the hawk suits comfortably within the hand and labored very properly scraping a big tinder ball of cedar bark.
I positioned the cedar bark underneath items of kindling I had chopped and by working the ferrocerium rod throughout the leading edge I used to be capable of simply produce numerous sparks and get a fireplace going.
As I discussed earlier, the top was reasonably boring upon arrival. After all of the testing, I took it into the store to repair the sting.
With a steel file, a sharpening stone, and about thirty minutes, I used to be capable of make the chopping much sharper and honed its profile.
Cold Steel Rifleman Pros and Cons
- Well balanced
- Comfortable one-handed or two-handed use
- Without the setscrew, the top is definitely eliminated for use as a hand instrument
- The bottom of the top works nice for impression duties
- Setscrew damages the deal with
- The leading edge was boring, and the steel head arrived in poor situation
CRKT Kangee Tomahawk Specifications
The Kangee head is constituted of 1055 carbon metal
The size of the leading edge is 4.21”
Made from Tennessee Hickory, the deal with is 19.13” lengthy and includes a lacquer end.
The Kangee weighs in at simply 1lb 15oz.
i’ve had the Kangee for a number of months now and i’ve come to love it.
The very first thing that I seen was that the steel head was not easy, nor did it have a mirror polish to it.
I do admire a mirror end on some instruments however finally it isn’t going to final if the instrument is getting used.
While I just like the “rough” look to the top’s floor, some individuals might not which is the one motive I convey it up.
Testing It Out
The Kangee is barely smaller and heavier than the Rifleman’s hawk however it’s nonetheless very comfy to hold on the beltline or on a pack.
It is properly balanced within the hand and is comfy to make use of with a low maintain or choked grip excessive up on the deal with.
Appearance-wise, the deal with has a wealthy coloration to it and a easy lacquer end.
While the lacquer end is interesting to the attention it doesn’t present an excellent grip, particularly in sweating hands.
The 19” deal with is nice for one-handed use and can be utilized two-handed, however it isn’t as comfy because the longer deal with of The Rifleman.
The head slips on and off the deal with simply and when pounded on, it holds exceptionally properly with little motion throughout use.
The leading edge was extremely sharp out of the container and I used to be capable of dry shave hairs from my arm.
After utilizing the Kangee on and off for a number of months it has retained its edge properly and i’ve but to sharpen it.
I put the Kangee by means of the identical chopping checks because the Rifleman above.
It did simply high quality chopping its approach by means of limbs of varied dimensions and the thicker cedar log.
When I moved as much as the bigger log and counted out ten swings, the reduce was nearly equivalent in depth to the Rifleman’s hawk.
Given that the profile of the Kangee head is barely thicker I didn’t suppose it was going to stay within the wood as much because it did. But it was simply eliminated with a few pulls of the deal with.
Opposite the leading edge is a protracted spike that involves a high quality level with solely the final portion of it being sharped.
By flipping the hawk round, the spike works nice for digging in comfortable soils and for different penetration duties.
If you’ve got by no means used a spiked tomahawk take your time utilizing it as it may be a bit unnerving at first.
The Kangee design is completely different than that of the peace pipe and it doesn’t have a flat floor on the again for hammering.
Although it isn’t as efficient, turning the Kangee sideways permits for the flat portion of the chopping head or the spherical part of the attention for use when pounding stakes into the bottom.
The deep groove on the underside of the top makes for a wonderful grip when holding the top as a hand instrument.
I used the top on this method to scrape cedar bark as I did earlier and paired with a ferrocerium rod I used to be capable of simply get a fireplace going.
As with The Rifleman hawk, I didn’t throw the Kangee however individuals who do are pleased with its efficiency.
The spike additionally permits for the Kangee to be thrown in two completely different orientations.
After a number of months of use, the leading edge was nonetheless in good working order however I made a decision to wash it up a little bit.
It solely took me a couple of minutes with a sharpening stone to the touch up the leading edge and produce it again to perfection.
CRKT Kangee Tomahawk Pros and Cons
- Razor-sharp out of the container
- Chops extraordinarily properly
- The spike is a really environment friendly penetration instrument
- The head is definitely eliminated and changed securely on the deal with
- The lacquer end turns into slick when hands are moist
- The deal with was not an ideal match for the top, daylight may very well be seen between the wood and the top
Rifleman Vs. Kangee at a Glance
Below is a desk that shortly summarizes the specs between these two instruments.
|Features||Rifleman’s Hawk||CRKT Kangee|
|Handle Material||American Hickory||Tennessee Hickory|
|Steel||5150 Carbon Steel||1055 Carbon Steel|
|Weight||1lb 10oz||1lb 15oz|
|Sheath||Not included||Not included|
Q: Why are the chopping heads not forever hooked up to the handles?
A: This is how tomahawks have been historically made, with a strain match, permitting for the steel head to be simply eliminated and used as a hand instrument. This additionally makes it much simpler to exchange a damaged deal with.
Q: Is there a strategy to forever repair these tomahawk heads to the handles?
A: I’m fairly positive the same process to hanging an ax deal with may very well be used. However, it’s extra frequent to make use of leather-based, or the fabric of your alternative, to wrap across the head and deal with. This might not be a “permanent” repair however it can definitely preserve the top safe if you don’t want to use it as a hand instrument.
Q: Can tomahawks be thrown?
A: Tomahawks are nice multitools. They can be utilized for chopping, scraping, digging, processing game and their compact dimension does makes them wonderful for throwing!
However, be ready that this activity requires numerous follow and has the potential for damaging the deal with.
Since these two hawks will not be the identical design and each did properly in my testing, I can not state that one is healthier than the opposite. But I can give you this.
The Cold Steel Rifleman is kind of a bit cheaper than the Kangee. In truth, after I ordered the Rifleman it was about half of the price of the Kangee.
If you’re searching for an inexpensive, plain-looking hawk and also you anticipate doing numerous hammering, then i’d counsel the Rifleman’s Tomahawk.
However, should you can spend a little bit extra money, want a extra completed trying deal with, and require a instrument that’s able to penetrating duties i’d counsel going with the CRKT Kangee.
Thanks for studying and keep sharp!
Do you’ve got any expertise with both of the tomahawks featured on this article? Sound off within the remark part under and tell us what you suppose!